Bedroom
Bedroom

Best Innerspring Mattress

Best Innerspring Mattress

Dating back to the 19th century, the innerspring (also known as a coil mattress or spring mattress) is the most popular mattress among consumers. Innersprings are fairly inexpensive, as well. The average innerspring costs between $900 and $1,100, but more affordable models are widely available.

Innerspring mattresses have a distinct feel. Traditional models are constructed with thin foam comfort layers and thick steel springs that make the surface feel very responsive and bouncy. Innersprings are also fairly breathable, thanks to strong airflow through their coil layers. Hybrids, a specific type of innerspring, feature comfort layers of memory foam or latex. These beds provide more of a balanced feel with closer body conforming and more pressure relief compared to classic innersprings.

Our top picks among innersprings sold today are listed below. We've based our selections on innerspring mattress reviews from verified owners, along with our own product research. Further down, we'll explore different types of innerspring coil systems and discuss the pros and cons of this mattress type.

Our Top Picks

Saatva
  • Mattress Type: Innerspring
  • Support Core: Recycled-Steel Bonnell Coils
    (13-Gauge)
  • Firmness Level: Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7-8)
  • Price: $1,199
Big Fig
  • Mattress Type: Hybrid
  • Support Core: Pocketed Coils
    (15-Gauge)
  • Firmness Level: Medium Firm (6)
  • Price: $1,699
The WinkBed
  • Mattress Type: Hybrid
  • Support Core: Pocketed Coils
    (Multi-Gauge)
  • Firmness Level: Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm/Plus (7-8)
  • Price: $1,599 (Standard), $1,799 (Plus)
Brooklyn Bedding Signature
  • Mattress Type: Hybrid
  • Support Core: Pocketed Coils (Multi-Gauge)
  • Firmness Level: Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7-8)
  • Price: $949
EcoCloud
  • Mattress Type: Hybrid
  • Support Core: Pocketed Coils (Multi-Gauge)
  • Firmness Level: Medium (5)
  • Price: $1,799
Helix Midnight
  • Mattress Type: Hybrid
  • Support Core: Pocketed Coils (16-Gauge)
  • Firmness Level: Medium Firm (6)
  • Price: $999

Saatva

Price: $1,199

Height: 11.5 or 14.5"

Firmness: Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7-8)

----

Pressure Point Relief: 4/5

Sleeps Cool:  4/5

Motion Isolation: 3/5 (Medium Soft); 2/5 (Medium Firm and Firm)

Edge Support: 3/5 (Medium Soft); 4/5 (Medium Firm and Firm)

Durability: 4/5

Ease of Movement:  4/5

Sex: 3/5 (Medium Soft), 4/5 (Medium Firm, Firm)

Off-Gassing: 5/5

Saatva Mattress

Highlights:

  • Multiple firmness and thickness options
  • Responsive and supportive coil-on-coil design
  • Strong airflow ensures very good temperature neutrality

Ideal For:

  • People who like the feel of a very responsive mattress
  • Hot sleepers
  • Those who prefer beds with thick profiles

The Saatva is one of our best spring mattress picks for a few reasons. The bed is constructed with a Euro-top cover containing comfort layers of polyfoam and memory foam, followed by a transitional layer of 14.5-gauge pocketed minicoils and a support core of 13-gauge steel Bonnell coils. This innovative coil-on-coil design creates a very responsive surface. Even by innerspring standards, this bed delivers some serious bounce. The dual coil layers also make the mattress feel exceptionally supportive, particularly for heavier individuals.

The Saatva is highly customizable. You can choose from three feels for your mattress – medium soft (4), medium firm (6), or firm (7-8) – based on your comfort and body-conforming preferences. The mattress is also available with an 11.5-inch profile and a 4-inch support core, or a 14.5-inch profile and a 7-inch support core. Those who prefer extra reinforcement should opt for the thicker profile, but either option offers robust support.

We also recommend the Saatva for hot sleepers. Both coil layers promote strong airflow to help the bed maintain a comfortable temperature. However, couples may find the mattress a bit disruptive because it does not isolate motion very well, and the Bonnell coils may produce loud squeaks from time to time.

The Saatva's price-point is very reasonable, and the company also offers free White Glove delivery within the contiguous U.S. This service, which includes in-home assembly and old mattress removal, typically costs at least $100. The Saatva is backed by a 120-night sleep trial and a 15-year warranty.

Read Our Full Saatva Mattress Review


Big Fig

Price: $1,699

Height: 13"

Firmness: Medium Firm (6)

----

Pressure Point Relief: 3/5

Sleeps Cool:  3/5

Motion Isolation: 3/5

Edge Support: 4/5

Durability: 4/5

Ease of Movement: 3/5

Sex: 3/5

Off-Gassing: 3/5

Big Fig Mattress

Highlights:

  • Durable latex and conforming foam layers
  • Robust edge support
  • Specifically designed for heavier individuals

Ideal For:

  • People who weigh at least 130 pounds
  • Sleepers who prefer very responsive mattresses
  • Those who need more edge support when getting in and out of bed

The Big Fig is one of the best innerspring mattress models designed for heavier people. The bed features a top layer of responsive latex, followed by three additional layers of high-density polyfoam. These materials offer an excellent balance of cushioning and support for people who weigh more than 200 pounds. The latex gives the surface a very responsive feel, while the foam contours to your body and reduces pressure points in your shoulders, hips, and other sensitive areas.

The support core consists of 15-gauge pocketed coils. This layer stabilizes the bed and maintains an even plane for larger sleepers, and also reinforces the edges against deep sinkage. The coils promote strong airflow to keep the mattress temperature-neutral, as well, and the latex layer is ventilated for added breathability.

Since the Big Fig is created with heavier people in mind, sleepers weighing less than 130 pounds may find the mattress too firm. However, anyone who weighs at least 130 pounds should find the bed adequately supportive – particularly back and stomach sleepers who tend to sink a bit on beds with weaker support systems.

The Big Fig is a little expensive, but still reasonably priced for a latex hybrid. Customers in the contiguous U.S. also receive free shipping. The mattress is backed by a 120-night sleep trial and a 20-year warranty.


The WinkBed

Price: $1,599 (Standard) or $1,799 (Plus)

Height: 13.5"

Firmness: Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), or Firm/Plus (7-8)

----

Pressure Point Relief: 3/5

Sleeps Cool: 4/5

Motion Isolation: 4/5 (Medium Soft); 3/5 (other firmness levels)

Edge Support: 4/5 (Medium Soft); 5/5 (other firmness levels)

Durability: 4/5 (Medium Soft, Medium Firm, and Firm); 5/5 (Plus)

Ease of Movement: 3/5 (Medium Soft and Plus); 4/5 (Medium Firm and Firm)

Sex: 3/5 (Medium Soft); 4/5 (other firmness levels)

Off-Gassing: 4/5 (Medium Soft, Medium Firm, and Firm); 3/5 (Plus)

Winkbed Plus Mattress

Highlights:

  • Four firmness options, including a Plus feel for heavier people
  • Zoned coils offer enhanced sleeper and edge support
  • Durable construction ensures a long lifespan

Ideal For:

  • Sleepers who prefer very responsive mattresses
  • Hot sleepers
  • Those who need more edge support when getting in and out of bed

The Winkbed by WinkBeds is another model – like the Saatva – with multiple firmness and design options. For the standard WinkBed, you can choose a medium soft (4), medium firm (6), or firm (7-8) feel. These models feature a gel-infused polyfoam comfort layer, pocketed minicoil transitional layer, and a pocketed coil support core. This coil-on-coil structure ensures exceptional responsiveness, as well as breathability.

If you weigh more than 200 pounds, then you may want to consider the WinkBed Plus instead. This firm (7-8) model is specifically designed for heavier individuals. It also has a polyfoam comfort layer, along with a transitional layer of latex over its pocketed coil support core. Although the WinkBed Plus is not a coil-on-coil model, the latex component provides a noticeable bounce, and also adds years to the bed's lifespan thanks to the material's natural durability.

Edge support is a key strength of all WinkBed models. The standard mattresses have coil systems divided into seven different gauge, or thickness, zones. Thicker low-gauge coils reinforce the perimeter against sinkage while thinner high-gauge coils offer enhanced support for your body. The WinkBed Plus has a three-zone support core that essentially achieves the same effect.

The WinkBed and WinkBed Plus have competitive price-points, given their high-quality hybrid construction. The company will also ship you a mattress free-of-charge if you reside in the contiguous U.S. The mattresses are backed by 120-night sleep trials and lifetime warranties.


Brooklyn Bedding Signature

Price: $949

Height: 11.5"

Firmness: Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), or Firm (7-8)

----

Pressure Point Relief: 4/5

Sleeps Cool: 3/5 (Medium Soft and Medium Firm); 4/5 (Firm)

Motion Isolation: 4/5 (Medium Soft and Medium Firm); 3/5 (Firm)

Edge Support: 3/5 (Medium Soft and Medium Firm); 4/5 (Firm)

Durability: 4/5

Ease of Movement: 3/5 (Medium Soft); 4/5 (Medium Firm and Firm)

Sex: 3/5 (Medium Soft); 4/5 (Medium Firm and Firm)

Off-Gassing: 4/5 (Medium Soft and Firm); 3/5 (Medium Firm)

brooklyn Bedding Signature

Highlights:

  • Pressure-relieving foam layers
  • Zoned coils provide strong edge support while cradling your body
  • Strong performance and durability at an affordable price

Ideal For:

  • Sleepers who like a combination of body-conforming and responsiveness
  • Those who have a hard time getting in and out of bed
  • Value seekers

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature is one of the best coil mattress models you can buy for less than $1,000 in a queen size. The bed's top layer is infused with cooling gel to help the surface minimize body heat build-up and sleep fairly cool, while the second layer is made of latex-like TitanFlex foam with strong responsiveness. These layers conform a bit while keeping your body level and resting above the surface.

Brooklyn Bedding offers three firmness levels for the Signature: medium soft (4), medium firm (6), and firm (7-8). The medium soft feel provides the closest contouring, so you may want to consider this model if you like a deeper body hug. The medium firm feel is the most balanced of the three, making it ideal for people who weigh between 130 and 200 pounds. Lastly, the firm feel does not conform much but it provides excellent support. If you weigh more than 200 pounds, this may be the best firmness for you.

Other strengths and weaknesses are associated with different firmness levels. The softer feels isolate motion better to eliminate transfer for couples, while the firmer options tend to sleep a bit cooler. All three offer great edge support thanks to their zoned pocketed coils, with 15.5-gauge coils reinforcing the perimeter.

In addition to giving the Signature a low price-point, Brooklyn Bedding also offers free shipping to all 50 states. The mattress comes with a 120-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty.


EcoCloud

Price: $1,799

Height: 13"

Firmness: Medium (5)

----

Pressure Point Relief: 4/5

Sleeps Cool: 4/5

Motion Isolation:  3/5

Edge Support: 4/5

Durability: 5/5

Ease of Movement: 4/5

Sex: 4/5

Off-Gassing: 4/5

EcoCloud Mattress

Highlights:

  • Durable latex hybrid construction
  • Comfort layer contours and reduces pressure while feeling very responsive
  • Great breathability and temperature neutrality

Ideal For:

  • People who weigh 200 pounds or less
  • Sleepers who prefer very responsive mattresses
  • Hot sleepers

The EcoCloud by WinkBeds is a latex hybrid model. Latex has a distinct feel from the polyfoam or memory foam layers found in other hybrids and innersprings. It is very responsive, for one, but it also contours to your body. This results in comfortable body-conforming and pressure relief without a deep sink. Latex also retains less body heat, so you won't feel as warm as you might on foam layers. Additionally, latex is very durable and will not sag or develop indentations as quickly.

The EcoCloud also excels at edge support thanks to its pocketed coil support core. The coils are divided into five gauge zones, with thinner coils to support your head, neck, shoulders, and legs, while thicker coils reduce sinkage along the edges and reinforce your midsection. Excessive sagging should not be an issue, and you'll feel very stable sleeping or sitting along the EcoCloud's edges.

Due to its medium (5) feel, the mattress is best suited to sleepers who weigh up to 200 pounds. Those who weigh more than 200 pounds may find the bed too soft – especially stomach sleepers, who typically need a firmer mattress to support their bodies and prevent excessive sagging.

The EcoCloud has a very reasonable price-point compared to other latex hybrids, and WinkBeds will ship the mattress for free anywhere in the contiguous U.S. You'll also receive 120 nights to test out the mattress, along with a lifetime warranty for extra peace of mind.


Helix Midnight

Price: $999

Height: 12"

Firmness: Medium Firm (6)

----

Pressure Point Relief: 4/5

Sleeps Cool: 3/5

Motion Isolation: 3/5

Edge Support: 3/5

Durability: 3/5

Ease of Movement: 3/5

Sex: 3/5

Off-Gassing: 3/5

Helix Midnight Mattress

Highlights:

  • Memory Foam Plus contours without sinking too much
  • Better-than-average pressure relief for a hybrid model
  • Steady airflow through pocketed coils helps to keep the mattress cool

Ideal For:

  • Back and side sleepers up to 200 pounds
  • Hot sleepers
  • Value seekers

In 2018, Helix Sleep revamped their mattress selection with a new hybrid line. Each model is uniquely designed to accommodate people with different body type and sleep position combinations. For our best innerspring mattress list, we've selected the Helix Midnight. This model is targeted at side sleepers, but its supportive medium (5) feel and premium comfort materials make the bed suitable for some back sleepers, too.

The comfort layer is made of Memory Foam Plus, which offers the same body-contouring as standard memory foam without the signature sink. This creates a somewhat responsive feeling as the material conforms to your body. The mattress also features a polyfoam transitional layer, followed by 16-gauge pocketed coils reinforced with high-density base foam. The coils also circulate air very well to keep the mattress cool.

We've found the Helix Midnight is comfortable and supportive enough for side and back sleepers up to 200 pounds. If you weigh more than 200 pounds and/or are a stomach sleeper, then the bed may feel too soft. Thankfully, Helix offers five more standard hybrids with varying firmness levels and materials, so you may be able to find another model that better meets your needs.

The Helix Midnight is another high-value pick due to its premium materials, strong overall performance, and reasonable price-point. Shipping is also free to all 50 states, and the mattress is backed by a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty.


Who Should Buy an Innerspring Mattress?

First and foremost, innersprings are the least expensive mattress type on average. You can easily find a high-quality innerspring for less than $1,000 in a queen size. Smaller options, such as a twin size innerspring, will cost even less.

Innersprings are very supportive, as well, thanks to their coil systems and thinner comfort layers. You won't feel much body-conforming, but the bed is designed to keep you on an even plane and support your entire body. Innersprings also sleep very cool due to their breathable coil systems.

Hybrids are a category of innerspring that usually feature latex and/or memory foam comfort layers, and pocketed coil support cores. Hybrids are similar to innersprings in some ways, but different in others. We'll discuss the pros and cons of each below.

How Does It Feel to Sleep on an Innerspring Mattress?

Innersprings and hybrids contain coil support systems that give them a different feel than other mattress types. You can count on the following characteristics from any high-quality innerspring or hybrid mattress.

  • Steady Airflow: The open coil systems in innerspring and hybrid support cores promote good air circulation to regulate the bed's temperature to help you sleep cool.
  • Strong Edge Support: With coils reinforcing the perimeter, you'll notice less sinkage when sitting or lying along the edges compared to all-foam or all-latex beds. This is especially true of innersprings and hybrids featuring zoned support cores with thicker edge coils.
  • Responsiveness: Thick coil systems create noticeable bounce on the surface, especially for innersprings with thinner comfort layers. Many couples prefer springy beds for sex. Hybrids can also feel fairly responsive, but their comfort layers may soften the effect.
  • Ease of Movement: Because they are responsive, innersprings – and, to a lesser extent, hybrids – are easier to move on than all-foam beds, which may pull sleepers in for a closer body hug and hinder movement in the process.

Are Innerspring Mattresses Supportive?

Innersprings and hybrids tend to be more supportive than other mattress types due to the extra reinforcement of their coil systems. That said, how supportive a mattress feels depends on that specific model and you, the sleeper.

Let's say you weigh more than 200 pounds. An innerspring with robust coils will likely provide more support than a mattress with a foam base. However, the innerspring should also be sufficiently firm. If the bed has a soft surface feel, you may still notice some uncomfortable sinking. The right combination of firmness and support is needed for people who weigh more than 200 pounds.

Back and stomach sleepers generally need more firmness and support, as well. These positions often lead to sagging beneath areas where people carry a disproportionate amount of weight, such as the torso and hips. Excessive sinkage can lead to aches and pains, so an innerspring or hybrid that keeps you on a flush, even plane is important for back and stomach sleeping.

What Are the Different Types of Innersprings?

Four types of coil systems are found in the vast majority of innersprings sold today. These coil types each have distinct pros and cons, as well as expected price ranges.

Bonnell Coils

Bonnell coils are generally found in low-priced mattresses. They consist of steel that has been molded into an hourglass shape, and each coil is joined together with wires known as helicals. Bonnell coils can withstand compression very well and are reasonably durable – but they can also be quite squeaky.

Offset Coils

Standard offset coils, like Bonnells, are formed from steel into an hourglass shape and linked with helicals. The key difference is the bottom of the coil, which has a hinge-like mechanism to reinforce the mattress when it is compressed. Double offset coils have top and bottom hinges, and free-arm offset coils are not joined with helicals. Offsets are quite durable and relatively quiet. You'll usually find them in more expensive beds.

Continuous Wire Coils

Continuous-wire coils consist of wire rows that extend the length of the mattress. Each row is joined with helicals for added support. These coils are fairly durable and offer great responsiveness for sex, but they do not promote much body-contouring. Expect to find continuous-wire coils in low-cost innersprings.

Pocketed Coils

Pocketed coils are encased in fabric or cloth. Instead of helicals, the coils are joined together using strands of fabric and hot glue. Pocketed coils offer the best contouring and motion isolation of any coil type, but they are also less durable. You can find them in some innersprings, but most mattresses with pocketed coils are considered hybrids and have higher price-points.

How Much Does an Innerspring Mattress Cost?

Innersprings with polyfoam comfort layers are generally low-priced. The average queen size innerspring mattress model costs between $900 and $1,100, but you'll be able to find cheaper options – $500 or lower, in some cases. This puts them on par with all-foam mattresses in terms of pricing.

Hybrids tend to be more expensive because they contain memory foam and/or latex. Although you can find plenty of hybrids for less, the average model costs between $1,600 and $2,200 in a queen size. All-latex mattresses share the same average price range.

Coil type may affect pricing. The price of an innerspring or hybrid also depends on where you buy your bed. Both mattress types are widely available at brick-and-mortar mattress stores, but these locations often mark up prices to compensate for higher overhead costs. Online brands, which generally do not operate physical stores, can afford to sell innersprings and hybrids for less.

What’s the Difference Between an Innerspring and a Hybrid?

The innerspring vs. hybrid discussion can get a little confusing. Hybrids are technically innersprings, but they occupy their own mattress category due to their specific designs. And while there are some distinctions between innersprings and hybrids, you'll also find some overlap with these two mattress types.

That said, the following table illustrates some general differences and similarities between innerspring and hybrid models.

Comfort Layer

Traditional innersprings have thinner comfort layers made of polyfoam, giving the surface a very responsive feel. Most hybrids have thick comfort layers of memory foam, latex, and other contouring materials. This creates a feeling akin to sleeping "on" and sleeping "in" the mattress at the same time.

Support Core

An innerspring may contain Bonnell, offset, continuous-wire, or pocketed coils. With a few exceptions, the mattresses we consider hybrids all contain pocketed coils.

Pros

Innersprings – especially models with thick coils – provide strong support for heavier people and back/stomach sleepers. They also offer great responsiveness for sex and above-average breathability for hot sleepers.

Hybrids can also be responsive, supportive, and temperature-neutral. But for many, their defining quality is a balance of body-contouring and responsiveness. You'll experience adequate pressure relief on most hybrids, as well as spinal alignment if you're a side sleeper, but the coil system will prevent your body from sagging too much.

Cons

Traditional innersprings have thinner comfort layers that are usually made of polyfoam, so you won't experience the same pressure-relieving cradle as you might on a hybrid with memory foam or latex. Additionally, many innersprings have below-average durability. You may notice uncomfortable sagging after only a few years of use.

Hybrids also have limited durability, though they tend to perform longer than traditional innersprings. This is especially true for hybrid models with latex comfort layers. And because they often have thick foam layers, hybrids may sleep a bit hotter than innersprings – though their coil systems generally promote good airflow.

Price

Price is a major distinction between innersprings and hybrids. As we noted above, the average innerspring costs between $900 and $1,100, while the average hybrid costs between $1,600 and $2,200.

How Long Will an Innerspring Mattress Last?

While the average mattress model has a lifespan of six to eight years, your innerspring will more likely last between five and seven years. The major issue for most owners is deep sagging. Traditional innersprings often feature cheaper polyfoam comfort layers that deteriorate somewhat quickly, and the mattress may feel uneven as the material softens and loses shape.

Coil systems can play a role in innerspring mattress longevity. Coil gauge, or thickness, is often a factor. Most coils have a gauge that falls between 12 (thickest) and 18 (thinnest). Beds with low-gauge coils typically provide longer-lasting support, but they may be less comfortable for sleeping. Models with zoned coils – low-gauge around the perimeter and high-gauge beneath your body – tend to offer the best combination of comfort and durability.

Many mattress brands will also tout durable mattresses with high "coil counts" but this claim is somewhat dubious, as there does not appear to be a major connection between the total number of coils and the bed's overall lifespan.

The average hybrid model will perform for six to seven years, which is slightly better than the average innerspring and on par with the average all-foam model. Latex and airbed mattresses, by comparison, typically last much longer. Hybrids with latex comfort layers will usually be much more durable than those with memory foam or polyfoam layers.

Rotating your innerspring or hybrid head-to-foot can prevent deep body indentations from forming, which in turn helps to preserve the bed's surface and extend its lifespan. We recommend doing this every three to six months. A mattress topper can also minimize sagging. In the next section, we'll take a closer look at what toppers are and how they work.

Last Things Before You Buy an Innerspring

Now that we've covered the nuts and bolts of innersprings and hybrids, let's close with a couple of practical things to consider about your mattress purchase.

Consider a Mattress Topper

A mattress topper is a layer of cushioning placed directly on top of your bed's surface. Toppers can be made from different materials, such as memory foam, latex, convoluted (egg-crate) polyfoam, or down and feathers. Most toppers are designed to make the mattress feel softer, but some offer a firmer feel.

Toppers can also preserve your mattress surface to minimize sagging and other types of wear and tear. Most toppers measure 2 to 5 inches thick, so they provide a decent buffer, and they cost much less than a new mattress. However, toppers aren't particularly durable, so using one to protect and optimize your bed's surface should be seen as a short-term solution.

Shipping Costs, Delivery, and Setting Up

If you order an innerspring or hybrid from an online mattress brand and you live in the contiguous 48 states, then good news: your shipping will most likely be free. Online brands use FedEx, USPS, and other third-party couriers for ground shipping, so you won't be able to schedule a specific delivery date.

Mattresses from online brands are usually compressed and vacuum-sealed in order to fit inside its shipping box. The courier will deposit the box on your doorstep, and you won't need to sign for it. To set up the mattress, bring the box into the room where you plan to use it. Open the box and place the compressed mattress on its foundation, then carefully cut open the plastic wrapping and watch the bed expand. The mattress should reach its full shape in 48 hours or less.

Online brands may also offer White Glove delivery. This service includes scheduled delivery, in-home setup, and old mattress removal. White Glove delivery normally costs at least $100, but a few brands provide it for free. The mattress will not be compressed for shipping in these instances. Some brands prefer not to compress their innerspring and hybrid models because their coil systems are more fragile than foam or latex. For this reason, White Glove delivery may be the only option for an innerspring or hybrid purchase.