Tuft & Needle vs. Casper: Which Should You Buy?
Both Leesa and Tuft and Needle debuted their flagship mattresses around the same time. These mattresses are among the most popular bed in a box options on the market, so it’s easy to understand why many people narrow down their mattress decision to the Leesa mattress vs. the Tuft and Needle mattress.
Leesa was founded in 2013, with a focus on high-quality mattresses and a socially conscious mission. Tuft and Needle launched their flagship mattress in 2014, made with premium materials at an affordable price point. While both companies have since expanded their product lines, we’ll focus on the original Leesa mattress and the original Tuft and Needle mattress here.
Both flagship mattresses are made with foam layers, but differ in overall feel, firmness, and construction. The Leesa mattress has a conforming layer of memory foam in its comfort system, while the Tuft and Needle mattress is made with a proprietary blend of Adaptive foam.
When comparing these two mattresses and determining which one is right for you, there are a few key factors to consider. Temperature regulation is always a concern when shopping for a foam mattress, as these mattresses often tend to retain heat. The main appeal of foam mattresses, on the other hand, is the amount of pressure point relief and body contouring they provide. Another deciding factor is price: which one of these mattresses is budget-friendly?
We provide a comprehensive breakdown of the Tuft and Needle mattress vs. the Leesa mattress. This direct comparison details the construction, firmness, and feel of both mattresses. We’ll cover both companies’ policies when it comes to shipping, sleep trials, returns, and warranties. We’ll also let you know which mattress we recommend based on your sleeping position, body type, and other preferences.
|Tuft & Needle||Tuft & Needle|
How Are These Mattresses Built?
There are several types of mattresses on the market, including foam, latex, hybrid, and airbed mattresses. The construction and materials used directly affect the durability of the mattress. High-quality materials ensure your mattress provides consistent, even support over time and prevent sagging.
Natural materials like latex and wool often have longer lifespans, while synthetic foam is less durable. However, when it comes to foam, the density of the foam is important to consider. High-density foam is less likely to break down or sag over time when compared to low-density foam. A foundation of high-quality, tempered steel coils can add durability to a mattress.
The Leesa mattress and Tuft and Needle mattress are foam mattresses. Both have a polyfoam base with a comfort system above. We’ll breakdown the specific materials used in both the Leesa mattress and the Tuft and Needle mattress here.
The Leesa mattress is 10 inches thick, which is the average height of a foam mattress. It is comprised of three layers of foam, including polyfoam and memory foam. All of the foams used are CertiPUR-US certified, meaning they are made without harmful chemicals and are low in Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs). Leesa adheres to strict social and environmental standards when manufacturing each mattress. The mattress is made in the United States.
The seamless cover of the Leesa mattress is made of a polyester blend that includes Lycra. This gives the cover some stretch and also helps it resist heat retention. The cover is breathable and soft and features Leesa’s signature four stripe design. Leesa recommends spot cleaning the mattress cover as needed, as it should not be removed. This is typical of most mattresses; few have covers that can be removed and machine washed. If you are concerned about keeping the cover spotless, consider using a mattress protector.
The first comfort layer of the Leesa mattress is 2 inches of high-density polyfoam. This layer is responsive, meaning it relieves pressure points and contours to the shape of your body when you lie down. This breathable foam offsets some of the heat retention that is common in foam mattresses. It also returns to its original shape faster than traditional memory foam, which gives the Leesa mattress a bit more bounce than you usually find with an all-foam bed. This makes it easier to change positions as needed, which is ideal if you are a combination sleeper.
Beneath the high-density polyfoam is a 2-inch layer of low-density memory foam. This layer provides the feeling of being “hugged” by the mattress, since it conforms closely and relieves pressure on the hips and shoulders. Memory foam also isolates motion exceptionally well, which prevents sleep disturbances if you share the bed.
The two comfort layers cushion areas that press into the mattress and distribute body weight evenly. This helps keep the spine in alignment, ultimately preventing stiffness and pain in the morning. The combination of layers also gives the Leesa mattress a unique feel. It relieves pressure points with close contouring, but also has a resilience that makes it easy to move on the mattress.
The foundation of the Leesa mattress is 6 inches of high-density polyfoam. As we’ve mentioned, high-density polyfoam is more durable than low-density foam. This base reinforces the comfort layers above it while increasing the amount of support throughout the mattress. It also improves the durability of the mattress.
Since the Leesa mattress is made entirely of foam, vacuum-sealed and compressed for shipment, there is the potential for off-gassing. Since the mattress is low in VOCs, the smell is not as strong as other foam mattresses. It should dissipate within a few days, especially in a well-ventilated room.
Tuft & Needle
The Tuft and Needle mattress also has a 10-inch profile and foam construction. Rather than three layers, the Tuft and Needle mattress has two layers. Tuft and Needle uses a proprietary foam blend, known as Adaptive foam. The support foam used in the mattress has an open cell structure for better temperature regulation.
The cover of the Tuft and Needle mattress is a micro polyamide and polyester blend. The cover is soft and textured. Like the Leesa mattress, the cover should not be removed and can only be spot cleaned.
The comfort layer of the Tuft and Needle mattress is 3 inches of proprietary Adaptive foam. This low-density polyfoam is unique in that it relieves pressure points and keeps the spine aligned without conforming too closely. The foam bounces back to its original shape as you move or change positions, giving it more resilience than memory foam. When Tuft and Needle designed this foam, they wanted it to have the benefits of both memory foam and latex without the drawbacks. As a result, the Adaptive foam gently contours for pressure relief without retaining heat. It is also less expensive than latex.
The Tuft and Needle Adaptive foam is infused with graphite and ceramic gel beads. The graphite actively draws heat away from your body as you sleep, which prevents the feeling of sleeping hot. The cooling ceramic gel beads wick away moisture and heat while offering support.
Beneath the comfort layer is a 7-inch foundation of open-cell polyfoam. This support foam is breathable and durable. It reinforces the comfort layer of Adaptive foam and prevents sinking into the mattress. This layer also contributes to the medium firm feel of the Tuft and Needle mattress.
Like the Leesa mattress, the Tuft and Needle mattress is made in the United States and is CertiPUR-US certified. The Tuft and Needle mattress is also GreenGuard Gold certified and the manufacturing process adheres to strict emissions standards. The mattress is likely to have an initial odor due to off-gassing, but it is minimal and should dissipate quickly.
How Do The Leesa and Tuft & Needle Mattresses Feel?
As the Leesa mattress and the Tuft and Needle mattress both feature an all-foam construction, there are similarities in terms of how they feel. Both mattresses offer pressure point relief and contouring that help to keep the spine aligned. Each mattress also has more resilience than traditional memory foam, resulting in added bounce.
The mattresses differ, however, when it comes to firmness. The Leesa mattress is softer than the Tuft and Needle mattress and uses memory foam in its comfort system for added contouring. The moderate contouring of the Tuft and Needle mattress prevents sinking in.
Comfort is certainly subjective, and how each mattress feels will depend on personal factors. Your body weight, sleeping position, and preferences should be taken into consideration. When we look at how a mattress feels, there are several key factors we keep in mind, which we’ll break down here.
The firmness of the mattress is one of the most important elements when it comes to comfort. How much bounce the mattress has, in addition to edge support and ease of movement, can determine if the mattress is a good choice for couples. Lastly, temperature regulation can prevent overheating and sweating and provide a more comfortable night’s rest.
When we talk about mattress firmness, it is on a scale of 1 (extremely soft) to 10 (extremely firm). Most mattresses fall in the middle of this scale, and are considered to be medium to medium firm. This firmness appeals to a wide range of body types and sleeping positions. Those who weigh less than 130 pounds tend to prefer a soft to medium soft mattress, while those who weigh more than 200 pounds typically choose a firm mattress. This is because firmness is subjective and can depend on how much pressure you apply to the mattress. What feels soft to a heavier sleeper may be too firm for someone who is lighter. Your sleeping position can also determine the firmness that you need.
The Leesa mattress has a medium firmness, right around a 5 on the firmness scale. This mattress conforms closely to the shape of your body, largely due to the responsive polyfoam and memory foam in the top layers. These layers alleviate pressure on the joints and prevent minor aches and pains. The medium firmness is ideal for side sleepers, as it cushions the shoulders and hips. Back sleepers who weigh less than 200 pounds will also feel supported by the Leesa mattress, as it provides lower back support and keeps the spine aligned.
The Tuft and Needle mattress is firmer than the Leesa mattress. Its medium firm feel falls at a 6 on the firmness scale. The low-density Adaptive foam contours to the shape of your body, without the cradling effect of memory foam. It is also resilient, so it bounces back to its original shape quickly as you change positions. The 7-inch, high-density polyfoam core prevents sinking deeply into the mattress. This combination of contouring and full-body support is ideal for nearly every sleeping position and body type. However, stomach sleepers who weigh more than 200 pounds may need a firm mattress in order to properly support their abdomen and hips.
How much bounce a mattress has is an important consideration, especially for couples. Bounce helps facilitate movement, making it easier to change positions during sex. It also prevents the feeling of being stuck in the mattress. This is useful for combination sleepers who shift from their back to their side or stomach throughout the night.
Both the Leesa and Tuft and Needle mattresses have more bounce than the average foam mattress. The Leesa mattress has a top layer of high-density polyfoam, which springs back to its original shape more quickly than traditional memory foam. Though there is a layer of memory foam beneath, this adds traction to the Leesa mattress, which is also important for sex. The high-density polyfoam base reinforces the comfort layers.
The Tuft and Needle mattress balances a conforming feel with moderate bounce. The Adaptive foam is resilient and springy, and you’ll notice it returns to its original shape when you change positions. The polyfoam base also prevents sinking into the mattress and helps facilitate movement.
Though both mattresses have more resilience than might be expected from a foam mattress, a hybrid or innerspring mattress is often the best bet for couples who want added bounce. Innerspring coils facilitate movement exceptionally well.
Edge Support and Ease of Movement
In addition to bounce, ease of movement and edge support are essential for couples sharing a bed. Ease of movement measures how well the mattress facilitates changing positions, whether you are shifting positions as you sleep or engaging in intimate activity. It prevents feeling restricted or trapped by the mattress.
Edge support refers to how supportive the bed is around the perimeter. While hybrid mattresses often have lower gauge coils around the perimeter for added edge support, foam mattresses are often lacking in this category. Edge support makes it easy to get in and out of bed, as it prevents the edges from sinking in when pressure is applied. It also increases the usable surface area of the bed by ensuring the perimeter is as supportive as the center. This is essential for couples who tend to sleep near the edges of the bed, rather than sharing the center.
When it comes to edge support, the Leesa and Tuft & Needle mattresses are comparable. Both mattresses lack a reinforced perimeter. As a result, you’ll notice sinking in along the perimeter when you sit on the edge of the bed. This makes it difficult to get in and out of bed, and could lead to sagging over time. The Leesa mattress is softer than the Tuft and Needle mattress, which makes it more prone to sinking in when pressure is applied. On the Tuft and Needle mattress, those who weigh less than 200 pounds should still feel supported when sleeping near the edge of the bed.
The Tuft and Needle mattress has a slight edge over the Leesa mattress when it comes to ease of movement. The Adaptive foam of the Tuft and Needle mattress springs back to its original shape faster than memory foam, making it easy to change positions. The foam also provides traction.
The Leesa mattress is relatively easy to move on, especially since the top layer is high-density polyfoam. The comfort system provides traction as well. It should be noted that the mattress is softer, so you are more likely to sink into the comfort layers on the Leesa mattress. This can lessen the ease of movement.
When considering a foam mattress, a common drawback is heat retention. Memory foam especially reacts to heat and pressure to conform closely to the shape of your body. This can prevent air from circulating around your body. Both the Leesa mattress and the Tuft and Needle mattress have better temperature regulation than the average foam mattress and are similarly rated when it comes to temperature neutrality.
The Leesa mattress has a cooling foam top layer with a breathable cover. This helps offset heat retention in the mattress. Since the memory foam is in the second layer, it is less likely to absorb body heat. The memory foam used also has a lower density. However, the Leesa mattress contours closely to the shape of your body, so airflow may be restricted to a certain extent.
The Tuft and Needle mattress has a low-density polyfoam in the comfort layer, which is infused with graphite and ceramic gel beads. This helps draw heat and moisture away from the body and disperses it, which prevents heat from building up in the mattress. Since you are also less likely to sink into the mattress, there is more room for airflow around your body. This gives the Tuft and Needle mattress an edge over the Leesa mattress, so we recommend it if you are a hot sleeper.
If you are deciding between the Tuft and Needle mattress and the Leesa mattress, know that you have two great options in front of you. Often, the choice will come down to personal preferences and needs. Based on our own product testing and review process, we’ll share our recommendations here.
Both mattresses are made with high-quality materials that offer pressure relief and full-body support. The average lifespan of a foam mattress is 6 to 8 years, and we expect both the Leesa and the Tuft and Needle mattress to last that long. Though both mattresses use low-density foams in the comfort layers, they each have a durable foam base.
These mattresses both offer benefits for couples. The foam construction of each mattress results in top-notch motion isolation. This prevents sleep disturbances for those who share the bed. Since both mattresses are silent when bearing weight, they are also discreet during sex.
The pressure relief capabilities of both the Leesa mattress and the Tuft & Needle mattress are worth noting. The Leesa mattress has a dual-layer comfort system with responsive polyfoam and memory foam, which conforms to the shape of your body and cushions areas like the shoulders, back, and hips. The unique Adaptive foam of the Tuft and Needle mattress offers moderate contouring.
Because the Leesa mattress is slightly softer, we find it’s a better fit for side sleepers. The added cushioning ensures the shoulders and hips are comfortably supported. This also helps keep the spine aligned. The added bounce and traction of the Leesa mattress also make it easy for combination sleepers to shift positions throughout the night.
The Tuft and Needle mattress is firmer, so we recommend it for back and stomach sleepers. This firmness prevents the lower back and hips from sinking into the mattress, which keeps the spine in proper alignment. The Tuft and Needle mattress also has better temperature regulation, which is ideal for people who tend to sleep hot.
While both the Tuft and Needle and Leesa mattresses are reasonably priced, the Tuft and Needle mattress is less expensive. For those shopping on a budget, the low price point of the Tuft and Needle mattress will be appealing.
Both companies have similar policies when it comes to shipping, returns, and warranty coverage. We’ll cover those in detail later on.
|Leesa||Tuft & Needle|
Though there are similarities between the Tuft and Needle mattress and the Leesa mattress, there are also key differences that set them apart. Shoppers looking for a budget-friendly option will immediately notice the price difference between the Tuft and Needle and Leesa mattresses. While the Leesa mattress is often available for less than $1,000, the Tuft and Needle mattress is even more affordable. Both companies offer seasonal promotions and discounts, but the difference in price is substantial.
In terms of construction, both are foam mattresses. However, the Leesa mattress has a three-layer construction that uses memory foam in the second layer. This gives it a more conforming feel for added pressure point relief. The Tuft and Needle mattress uses a proprietary blend of polyfoam, infused with gel and graphite to draw heat away from the body. The two-layer construction of the Tuft and Needle mattress is less conforming.
The Leesa mattress is also softer than the Tuft and Needle mattress. Coming in at a 5 on the firmness scale, the Leesa mattress contours closely so that you feel more like you are sleeping “in” the mattress. The Tuft and Needle mattress is considered to be medium firm (6), so there is less sinking in. This gives the feeling of sleeping “on” the mattress.
These differences can help you decide which mattress may be a better fit, based on your own preferences and priorities.
Beyond their flagship mattresses, both Leesa and Tuft and Needle offer additional mattress models. We have listed these below.
- Leesa Hybrid: The Leesa hybrid mattress has an 11-inch profile with an aerated foam comfort layer and responsive pocket springs.
- Leesa Legend: The Leesa Legend mattress has a 12-inch profile with a dual-spring construction. A micro-pocket spring layer sits on top of an active response pocket coil base.
- Tuft and Needle Mint: The Mint mattress is an all-foam option with a 12-inch profile and thicker comfort layers. This mattress includes enhanced Adaptive foam.
- Tuft and Needle Hybrid: The Tuft and Needle hybrid mattress combines Adaptive foam with pocketed innerspring coils. This mattress also has a nano coil transition layer.
When shopping online for a mattress, be sure to read the shipping, return, and warranty policies of the company. Many online mattress companies offer similar sleep trials and warranties, though you will want to understand the fine print. Since you are not able to try out the mattress before purchasing, the sleep trial and return process can play an important role in the decision-making process. That being said, Leesa and Tuft and Needle have similar policies when it comes to shipping, returns, and warranty coverage.
Leesa offers free ground shipping to all 50 states. The company also has a White Glove Delivery and old mattress removal option for $150. International shipping is available to Canada, Germany, and the United Kingdom for an additional charge.
Tuft and Needle offers free shipping within the contiguous United States. There is an additional charge for orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii. In some major cities, same-day delivery is available for $50. White Glove Delivery with old mattress removal is available in the contiguous United States for $150.
Leesa offers a 100-night sleep trial, which begins when the mattress is delivered. Leesa asks that you try the mattress for a minimum of 30 nights before initiating a return. This gives your body time to adjust to the new mattress before making a decision.
Tuft and Needle also has a 100-night sleep trial, with no required break-in period. If you are someone who wants to be able to return the mattress quickly if it is not what you expected, this may be a better choice.
If you decide to return the Leesa mattress, the company coordinates the pick-up and donation of the mattress. For returns made in Alaska and Hawaii, there is a $100 return fee. Once the mattress is picked up and donated, Leesa provides a refund.
Tuft and Needle offers free returns. The company helps coordinate the donation of your mattress. Once the donation is confirmed, Tuft and Needle issues a refund for the mattress. Original shipping charges, including White Glove Delivery fees, are non-refundable.
Both companies offer a 10-year warranty. Leesa will repair or replace a defective mattress, but the customer is responsible for shipping and transportation charges. Tuft and Needle will repair or replace a defective mattress at no charge to the customer.