Mattress shopping has changed in the past decade. With the prevalence of online companies, bed in a box mattresses delivered to your front door, and generous sleep trials, it is easier than ever to try out a new mattress. If you’ve done your research and narrowed it down to the Nectar mattress vs. the Tuft and Needle mattress, we’re here to help.
Tuft & Needle launched in 2014 with a primary focus on simplifying the mattress shopping experience by offering a high-quality mattress at an affordable price point. The original Tuft and Needle mattress, which we’ll focus on in this review, continues to be one of the most popular foam mattresses. The company uses a proprietary blend of foam that relieves pressure points and prevents heat retention.
Easily just as popular, the original Nectar mattress was introduced in 2016. Nectar also focuses on competitive pricing and using high-quality materials. The Nectar mattress is constructed with multiple layers of memory foam for close contouring and pressure relief.
Foam models like the Tuft & Needle mattress and the Nectar mattress typically appeal to those who need additional pressure point relief, or those who have chronic back pain. They are also ideal for couples who prioritize motion isolation and want to minimize sleep disturbances throughout the night.
When comparing the Tuft and Needle mattress vs. the Nectar mattress, you might be wondering, which one sleeps cooler? Is one better at pressure relief than the other?
We’ll break down how each mattress performs when it comes to these and other key factors. Our direct comparison will help you decide which mattress better suits your needs. We’ll also give you an idea of how each mattress feels in terms of firmness, contouring, and support. Additionally, we’ll make recommendations based on our own product research and verified customer feedback, and review each company’s policies.
|Nectar||Tuft & Needle|
How Are These Mattresses Built?
Both the Nectar and Tuft & Needle mattresses are made with foam layers. When it comes to choosing a mattress type, there are several options. Foam, latex, hybrid, and airbed mattresses are all common. A mattress is usually constructed with one to two comfort layers and a transition layer above the foundation. The type of mattress you choose and the quality of materials it is made with directly affect the lifespan of the mattress.
Natural latex mattresses typically have a long lifespan, as latex is less likely to sag over time. A hybrid mattress can offer consistent support for years to come, as long as the coils are high-quality. For foam mattresses, high-density foam is usually more durable than low-density foam. In general, premium materials and workmanship increase the lifespan of the mattress.
Both Nectar and Tuft & Needle use high-quality materials. We’ll break down how each mattress is built here.
The Nectar mattress is constructed of five layers of foam. The mattress is slightly taller than the average mattress, with an 11-inch profile. This helps prevent sinking in deeply and feeling the support layer of the mattress.
The cover of the Nectar mattress is made with Tencel long-staple fiber, which is breathable and moisture-wicking. The fabric is quilted with a 1-inch layer of gel-infused memory foam. The bottom of the mattress cover helps keep the mattress in place on the bed frame. The cover should not be removed, but it can be spot cleaned as needed. If you like to keep your mattress spotless, Nectar recommends using a mattress protector.
Beneath the quilted cover is another 1-inch layer of gel-infused memory foam. This layer relieves pressure on the neck, shoulders, hips, and joints. It also helps evenly distribute body weight. The gel draws heat away from the body, which offsets some of the heat retention that is common with memory foam.
The Nectar mattress has a transition layer of adaptive hi-core memory foam. This layer is 3 inches thick and relieves pressure points. It contours to the shape of the body, which helps keep the spine aligned and prevents aches and pains. This layer also reduces the likelihood of sagging and deep impressions in the mattress over time.
Having three layers of memory foam in the Nectar mattress results in top-notch motion isolation. If you move on one side of the bed, that movement is absorbed and does not transfer to other parts of the bed. For couples who share the bed, this minimizes sleep disturbances throughout the night. The foam construction also means the Nectar mattress is silent when bearing weight.
The foundation of the Nectar mattress is a stabilizing base layer of super core support foam. This 6-inch support core reinforces the layers above and provides consistent support from edge to edge. This gives the Nectar mattress better than average edge support, which we’ll discuss later in-depth. It also contributes to the medium firm feel of the mattress.
The foams used in the Nectar mattress are CertiPUR-US certified, meaning they are low in Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs) and made without the use of harmful chemicals. This results in less off-gassing, though there is an initial odor from the foams and packaging when the mattress is unboxed. This smell is common with foam mattresses and should dissipate quickly.
Tuft & Needle
The Tuft & Needle mattress has a 10-inch profile, which we consider to be the average height for a foam mattress. The construction includes two layers of polyfoam. While most mattresses have multiple comfort layers, or a transition layer above the base, the Tuft and Needle mattress relies on a thick, single comfort layer of Adaptive foam instead.
The soft and breathable cover of the T&N mattress is made with a micro polyamide and polyester blend. This allows air to flow through the mattress cover. The mattress cover is not removable and should be spot cleaned as needed.
The comfort layer of the Tuft & Needle mattress is 3 inches of T&N Adaptive foam. This proprietary blend of polyfoam includes graphite and ceramic gel beads. Graphite actively draws heat away from the body and dissipates it. The ceramic gel beads wick away moisture and heat while cushioning and supporting the body. This foam layer is low-density and prevents heat retention.
The moderate contouring of the Adaptive foam layer also reduces back and joint pain. It cushions areas that press into the mattress, including the shoulders and hips. This helps keep the spine aligned, regardless of your sleeping position.
T&N Adaptive foam also has more resilience than traditional memory foam, so it bounces back to its original shape quickly. This makes it easier to move throughout the night as needed, and you won’t feel trapped or restricted by the mattress. The polyfoam also does a good job of preventing motion transfer and minimizing sleep disturbances. The mattress is silent when bearing weight.
Beneath the thick comfort layer is a 7-inch foundation of high-density polyfoam. This foam base reinforces the Adaptive foam comfort layer and prevents sinking into the mattress. It also contributes to the medium firm feel of the T&N mattress. This polyfoam has an open-cell structure, which increases airflow throughout the mattress and keeps heat from building up. Heat retention is a common concern with most foam mattresses, so this makes the Tuft & Needle mattress better than average when it comes to temperature regulation.
The Tuft & Needle mattress is Greenguard Gold and CertiPUR-US certified. The mattress is made without harmful chemicals and low in VOCs. The manufacturing process adheres to strict regulations when it comes to chemical emissions. There is some off-gassing to be expected when the T&N mattress is first unboxed, though it dissipates quickly in a well-ventilated room.
How Do The Nectar and Tuft & Needle Mattresses Feel?
The Nectar and Tuft & Needle mattress both offer pressure point relief with a medium firm feel. However, there are significant differences in the materials used in each mattress. This affects how both mattresses feel from the moment you lie down.
Many people enjoy the conforming feel of memory foam. The Nectar mattress contours closely to the shape of your body since it has three layers of memory foam. This gives you the feeling of sleeping “in” the mattress. The Tuft & Needle mattress, on the other hand, uses resilient polyfoam that results in the feeling of sleeping “on” the mattress.
These differences affect more than just the overall feel of each mattress. They also have an impact on how much bounce each mattress has, whether or not there is ample edge support, and how easy it is to move or change positions as needed. We’ll break down these key categories here.
When we talk about mattress firmness, we use a scale of 1 (extremely soft) to 10 (extremely firm). Firmness is a subjective measurement of comfort, and is directly affected by how much you weigh and what position you sleep in. But this scale helps us directly compare how mattresses feel. The majority of mattresses are going to fall near the middle of this scale, and are not likely to be on either extreme end of the firmness scale. Medium to medium firm mattresses appeal to a wide range of body types, sleeping positions, and comfort preferences.
Both the Nectar and Tuft & Needle mattresses are considered to be medium firm, or a 6 on the firmness scale. This level of firmness balances comfort and full-body support, and it is ideal for sleepers who weigh between 130 and 200 pounds.
Though they have the same firmness rating, the mattresses feel different.
The Nectar mattress has three layers of memory foam with a supportive base. The comfort system hugs the body and provides immediate pressure point relief. That conforming feel is to be expected from memory foam. The medium firmness of the Nectar mattress cushions the shoulders and hips, without letting either area sink in too deeply. This keeps the spine aligned.
This balance is ideal for stomach sleepers of all body types. It keeps the hips and abdomen from dipping too low, while also cushioning the chest. It is also a good fit for side and back sleepers who weigh more than 130 pounds.
The Tuft & Needle mattress doesn’t hug or conform to the shape of the body in the same way that the Nectar mattress does. The comfort layer of T&N Adaptive foam relieves pressure but keeps you from sinking into the mattress. It is a more buoyant foam, so it results in the feeling of sleeping on top of the mattress. The low-density polyfoam on top of a high-density foam base helps keep the spine aligned.
This combination offers excellent support for back and side sleepers who weigh less than 200 pounds. It is also supportive enough for stomach sleepers in this weight category, as it reduces pressure on the lower back by supporting the hips and abdomen.
Bounce in a mattress helps facilitate movement and prevents feeling stuck. This is an essential factor for sex, since it makes it easier to change positions as needed. A mattress constructed with resilient foam, latex, and/or innerspring coils will have more bounce than one made with plush, conforming memory foam. When a mattress has little to no bounce, it can be difficult to move around on the mattress.
The Tuft & Needle mattress has more bounce than the Nectar mattress. This is because the T&N mattress is made with a thick layer of Adaptive foam that is more resilient and buoyant than memory foam. The Adaptive foam springs back to its original shape when you shift or change positions. This means you won’t feel stuck in the mattress, as it keeps you from sinking in. The high-density polyfoam base reinforces this layer.
The Nectar mattress still has some bounce, though the thick layers of memory foam conform more to the shape of your body. Its stronger degree of conforming can cause you to sink into the mattress more, which restricts movement to a certain extent. At the same time, this can provide more traction, which is helpful for changing positions. The medium firm feel and high-density base reinforce the memory foam comfort system.
Edge Support and Ease of Movement
Edge support and ease of movement should be considered, especially if you share the bed with a partner. Edge support indicates how the perimeter of the mattress holds up under pressure. Does it feel as supportive as the center of the mattress? If it sinks in when you sit on the edge, this could lead to sagging over time.
These factors are especially important for couples. Edge support ensures someone who sleeps on the edge of the bed is as supported as someone who sleeps near the center. For couples who share the bed, this prevents feeling crowded. It makes a small mattress feel bigger because it increases the usable surface area of the bed. This is essential for sleeping as well as for sex.
Ease of movement makes it easier to change positions during sex. It also makes it easier for combination sleepers to shift from their side to their stomach or back throughout the night.
In terms of edge support, the Nectar mattress has high-density foam layers that ensure the mattress has consistent support from edge to edge. This gives it better edge support than expected for a foam mattress. There is still noticeable sinkage when you sit on the edge of the bed, but those who sleep near the edge should feel supported.
The Tuft & Needle mattress uses low-density foam for its comfort layer, giving it slightly less edge support than the Nectar mattress. Again, this is most noticeable when you sit on the edge of the bed. Though the polyfoam springs back to its original shape, if you regularly sit on the edge of the bed you may notice some sagging over time.
When it comes to ease of movement, Tuft & Needle has a slight advantage over the Nectar mattress. The Adaptive foam is springy and resilient. As a result, it facilitates movement better and makes it easier to change positions. This makes it better for sex, as well as ideal for combination sleepers.
The Nectar mattress has a medium firm feel and more bounce than the average memory foam mattress. The adaptive hi-core memory foam ensures you don’t sink too deeply into the mattress, which helps facilitate movement. Memory foam is just less resilient than T&N Adaptive foam.
A common concern with foam mattresses is their tendency to retain heat. Traditional memory foam reacts to heat and pressure to conform closely. This cushions pressure points and provides customized support, but it also restricts airflow. Both Nectar and Tuft & Needle take measures to offset heat retention and regulate temperature.
The Nectar mattress has a breathable lyocell cover, which wicks away heat and moisture. The two layers of gel-infused memory foam beneath draw heat away from the body. Since all three top layers of the Nectar mattress are memory foam, the mattress conforms closely and can restrict airflow. If you tend to sleep hot, the Nectar mattress would not be our top pick.
The Tuft & Needle mattress sleeps cooler than the Nectar mattress, since it does not use memory foam in its comfort system. The top layer of Adaptive foam is infused with ceramic gel beads and graphite, two elements that draw heat and moisture away. Polyfoam is more breathable than memory foam and the base of the T&N mattress has an open-cell structure for added airflow. There is still the possibility of heat retention, but between the Nectar vs. the Tuft and Needle mattress, we would recommend the Tuft and Needle mattress if you sleep hot.
When deciding between Nectar vs. Tuft and Needle, ultimately the decision is up to you. Both mattresses are great options, but one may be better suited for you depending on your personal preferences, body type, and sleep position. Based on our own research, we’ll break down our recommendations here.
The Nectar mattress and the Tuft & Needle mattress are both made with high-quality materials that translate to above-average durability. As with all foam mattresses, there is the potential for sagging or impressions over time. This is more likely for sleepers who weigh more than 200 pounds. Rotating the mattress 180 degrees (head to foot) every few months can reduce this risk.
Both mattresses are medium firm and provide pressure relief for the shoulders, hips, and joints. This helps reduce aches and pains. The Nectar mattress has a cradling effect that is ideal for side sleepers, especially those who weigh more than 130 pounds. The multiple layers of memory foam cushion the shoulders and hips. For stomach sleepers, the Nectar mattress prevents the hips and abdomen from dipping too low while still cushioning the chest.
The Nectar mattress also has superior motion isolation. This makes it an ideal choice for couples, as it prevents movement from transferring across the bed. It is also silent when bearing weight. This results in fewer sleep disturbances, especially if your partner has a different sleep schedule than you or is prone to tossing and turning.
The Tuft & Needle mattress is ideal for back and combination sleepers. Back sleepers will find their lower back is properly supported and their spine is kept in alignment. Combo sleepers will benefit from the added bounce of the T&N adaptive foam, which helps when changing positions throughout the night. The cooling nature of the T&N adaptive foam also prevents heat buildup in the mattress. This makes it a better choice for anyone who sleeps hot.
Both mattresses are competitively priced, but the Tuft & Needle is the more affordable choice. Nectar and Tuft & Needle frequently offer discounts and promotions.
|Nectar||Tuft & Needle|
The Tuft & Needle mattress and the Nectar Sleep mattress are similar in terms of firmness and pressure relief. Both are made with premium materials that increase the lifespan and durability of the mattress. But there are key differences that should be considered before deciding between the two.
There is a stark contrast in the comfort layers of each mattress. If you like the feeling of sleeping “in” your mattress, the conforming feel of the Nectar mattress will be a better fit. Three layers of memory foam contour closely to the shape of your body, so you’ll feel hugged and supported.
If you prefer the feeling of sleeping “on” the mattress, the Tuft & Needle mattress fits the bill. The thick layer of Adaptive foam ensures you won’t sink deeply into the mattress. It also offers pressure point relief without closely conforming.
When it comes to temperature regulation, the Tuft & Needle mattress performs better. The mattress has more airflow throughout each layer, thanks to an open-cell polyfoam base and graphite-infused Adaptive foam. The breathable cover wicks away heat and moisture. Though there is always a possibility of heat retention with any foam mattress, the Tuft and Needle mattress does a good job of encouraging airflow and dissipating heat.
The Tuft & Needle mattress is also more affordable. There is a wide range of price points when it comes to foam mattresses, but on average a queen size mattress will cost between $1,000 and $1,500. Both Nectar and Tuft & Needle are competitively priced, but Tuft & Needle is even more budget-friendly.
In addition to their flagship models, both Tuft & Needle and Nectar Sleep offer additional mattresses. We’ll highlight each model here:
- Nectar Lush: The Nectar Lush is a 12-inch foam mattress that is softer than the original Nectar mattress for even more pressure point relief. The mattress also has dual-action cooling, with a breathable cover and gel foam.
Tuft & Needle has two other models to choose from:
- Tuft & Needle Mint: The T&N Mint mattress is a 12-inch foam mattress with enhanced T&N Adaptive foam. This mattress has 3 layers instead of 2, with more graphite and reinforced edge support.
- Tuft & Needle Hybrid: The T&N Hybrid mattress has a multi-layer design with Adaptive foam comfort layers, a microcoil transition layer, and pocketed springs. The pillow-top of the mattress is infused with carbon.
In addition to considering which mattress will better suit your needs, we also recommend understanding each company’s policies before making a purchase. You’ll want to know if there are shipping charges, how long it will take to receive your order, and how it will be shipped.
Most, if not all, online mattress companies offer a sleep trial, giving you a chance to try out the mattress in your own home. Since online shopping does not give you the opportunity to feel the mattress before making a purchase, this is an important component. Warranty coverage can also be an indicator of quality and durability.
Nectar offers free ground shipping within the contiguous United States. The mattress is shipped compressed and vacuum-sealed, and is delivered to your front door. Additional charges apply for orders shipped to Hawaii and Alaska. If you prefer White Glove Delivery, Nectar offers this service for $149. This includes the removal of your old mattress.
Similarly, Tuft & Needle has free ground shipping within the contiguous United States. Additional charges apply for Alaska and Hawaii. Same-day delivery is available for $50 in the following major cities: New York City, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Seattle, Phoenix, Portland, and Dallas. White Glove Delivery with old mattress removal is available for $150.
For Nectar, the 365-night sleep trial begins 30 days after the mattress is delivered. This gives you time to adjust to the mattress before initiating a return. Nectar offers one of the most generous sleep trials on the market. Having a full year is beneficial for anyone who likes to take their time with decisions, or those who want to see how the mattress feels in each season.
Tuft & Needle offers a 100-night sleep trial, which begins when the mattress is delivered. There is no break-in period, so you can initiate a return right away if you decide the mattress is not right for you.
The return process for both companies is relatively simple. Both Nectar and Tuft & Needle offer free returns and help coordinate the pick-up and donation of the mattress.
When it comes to warranty coverage, Nectar offers a forever warranty. For the first 10 years of the warranty, Nectar will replace a defective mattress at no cost to the customer. After 10 years, Nectar will repair or replace your mattress with a $50 shipping charge each way. This charge is waived if a defect is found.
Nectar’s lifetime warranty gives it an advantage over Tuft & Needle, which offers a 10-year warranty. Tuft & Needle will replace or repair a defective mattress free of charge within the 10-year period.