Finding the best mattress can be a difficult undertaking because a mattress that feels comfortable and provides enough support for you may be inadequate for someone else, and vice versa. We encourage our readers to determine their ideal firmness level, create a realistic budget, and research different mattress brands and models to find their most suitable options.
Our expert team has personally evaluated hundreds of mattresses. During these hands-on tests, we determine how well each mattress performs in terms of durability, pressure relief, temperature regulation, and other qualities that matter most to sleepers. The models that earn the best ratings in certain categories during our tests may not necessarily be the best fit for you. Rather, we hope to provide a helpful jumping-off point for finding your ideal mattress.
We’ll discuss everything you need to know about buying a new mattress. We cover common mattress types and materials, strategies for figuring out your ideal firmness level, and important details about mattress shipping, returns, and warranties.
Top Picks Overview
Our Top Picks
Saatva ClassicBest Overall
- Highly supportive coil-on-coil construction
- Multiple firmness and profile options
- Free White Glove delivery for all orders
The Saatva Classic builds on the traditional innerspring with features designed to help you sleep more comfortably. The mattress’ top layer consists of soft polyfoam encased in a Euro-top cover, creating a plush feel. Beneath it lies a layer of memory foam that conforms evenly for enhanced lumbar and hip support. The transitional layer consists of pocketed microcoils that reinforce the comfort layers without causing uncomfortable stiffness. Sturdy, low-gauge hourglass coils composed of recycled steel make up the support core.
The Saatva Classic’s coil-on-coil design provides excellent overall stability, especially around the perimeter where less supportive mattresses tend to buckle and sink. The coils also promote consistent airflow to maintain a cool temperature throughout the interior. Additionally, a cover made of breathable organic cotton encases the entire mattress for added cooling on the surface.
Customers have a few options when selecting their Saatva Classic. The mattress is available in three firmness levels: soft (3), medium firm (6), and firm (8). Each feel offers a distinct balance of contouring and support. The soft option is best suited to side sleepers who weigh up to 230 pounds, as well as back and stomach sleepers under 130 pounds. The firm feel is most supportive, allowing back and stomach sleepers weighing 130 pounds or more to lie comfortably without sinking. The medium firm feel is a mid-level option for anyone who weighs 130 to 230 pounds. The Saatva Classic is also available in profiles of 11.5 or 14.5 inches, depending on your preferred thickness.
Unlike most competing mattress-in-a-box brands, Saatva provides free White Glove delivery for all orders. Couriers schedule a delivery date and time with you, set up the mattress in a room of your choice, and haul away your old mattress and box spring at no extra charge. The Classic comes with a 180-night sleep trial and a 15-year warranty.
Nectar MattressBest Value
- Cooling components help prevent excessive heat buildup
- Superior motion isolation for couples
- Competitive pricing and year-long trial period
A memory foam mattress is generally a great investment for anyone who experiences persistent pain or pressure points in the shoulders, lower back, or hips. The Nectar Mattress is constructed with a memory foam comfort layer that contours evenly to improve spinal alignment and alleviate discomfort in these areas, and it carries a more affordable price-point than many competing models of comparable quality.
Beneath the comfort layer, transitional and base layers of dense polyfoam help prevent excessive sinking. A medium firm (6) feel makes the Nectar Mattress best suited for side sleepers who weigh at least 130 pounds, and back and stomach sleepers who weigh up to 230 pounds. Another benefit of the bed’s all-foam design is above-average motion isolation. Each layer absorbs movement to prevent disruptive motion transfer across the surface, which can curb sleep interruptions for you and your partner when the other person moves in bed.
The memory foam is infused with phase change material designed to capture and disperse body heat. This component helps to offset the foam’s heat-trapping tendencies and keeps you cool while you sleep. The cover is also fairly breathable.
All customers in the contiguous U.S. enjoy free ground shipping with their mattress order. Nectar’s 365-night sleep trial is one of the longest in the industry, and each order includes a lifetime warranty that covers the mattress as long as you own it.
Helix MidnightMost Comfortable
- Memory foam comfort layer gently contours to the body
- Reinforced coils protect the edges from excessive sinkage
- Steady airflow for above-average cooling
Helix Sleep offers an extensive selection of hybrid mattresses. Each model is designed for people with specific body types and preferred sleep positions, and visitors to the Helix website are invited to complete a questionnaire that determines their best matches. The Helix Midnight is the most balanced and well-rounded of the brand’s standard hybrid lineup. With a medium firm (6) feel, the Midnight caters to sleepers looking for a combination of gentle contouring and sturdy support.
The memory foam comfort layer cradles and conforms to the body, alleviating pressure in sensitive areas along the spine, while the polyfoam transitional layer offers additional cushioning and prevents you from sinking too deeply into the mattress. A support core of pocketed coils completes the hybrid design. These coils are reinforced along the edges to maintain a stable perimeter when you get in and out of bed. Consistent air circulation through the coil layer also keeps the mattress cool and reduces heat retention.
The Midnight’s unique design is geared toward side sleepers who weigh 130 to 230 pounds, as well as back and stomach sleepers who weigh less than 130 pounds. If this doesn’t match your description, Helix offers five additional hybrids with varying firmness levels that accommodate other weight and sleep position categories. You can also select a model from the Luxe collection, which builds on the standard hybrid designs with pillow-top surfaces and zoned coil systems.
Compared to other hybrid models, the Midnight has a below-average price-point. Helix also offers free ground shipping to customers in all 50 states. Mattress returns are allowed within 100 nights of the delivery date. Each order is backed by a 10-year warranty.
DreamCloud Premier RestBest Luxury
- Luxurious pillow-top hybrid construction
- Cooling cashmere-blend cover and strong airflow throughout the interior
- 365-night trial and lifetime warranty
DreamCloud specializes in premium mattresses sold at approachable price-points, and the Premier Rest is the brand’s high-end model. Measuring 16 inches in height, the mattress includes a pillow-top cushioned with soft memory foam, a support core of zoned pocketed coils, and a plush cashmere-blend cover. Models of comparable quality are often expensive, but the Premier Rest is affordable in comparison.
The mattress has a medium (5) firmness level. Thick foam layers contour evenly to align the spine, distribute your weight, and reduce pressure along the spine. The foam also isolates movement to help reduce sleep disturbances for couples.
A support core of 8.5-inch pocketed coils and dense base foam provides excellent overall stability. Since the coils are reinforced along the perimeter, deep sinkage should not be an issue when you sit along or sleep near the edges. The cashmere-blend cover that encases the entire mattress helps the surface stay cool and also wicks away moisture to help keep you dry.
Customers in the contiguous U.S. qualify for free ground delivery. DreamCloud’s sleep trial allows you to test out the mattress for a full year. The mattress is also backed by a lifetime warranty.
Layla MattressBest for Side Sleepers
- Reversible design with a different feel on each side
- Copper-infused memory foam engineered to resist heat buildup
- Excellent motion isolation
The Layla Mattress is a flippable model, with a different firmness level on each side. One side of the mattress offers a medium soft (4) feel with ample cushioning and deep contouring. This firmness level is most suitable for side sleepers who weigh up to 230 pounds, as well as lighter individuals who prefer back or stomach positions. The opposite surface has a firm (7) feel, which should provide adequate support for back and stomach sleepers weighing more than 130 pounds.
Each comfort layer is composed of memory foam infused with copper, which is intended to help the foam maintain a comfortable temperature. A shared support core of high-density foam rests between the memory foam layers. The queen size mattress weighs 69 pounds, making it easier to flip whenever you want to change the firmness level.
Although the memory foam layers offer different levels of cushioning, both conform evenly to distribute weight and improve alignment, making the mattress an excellent option for those seeking pressure relief. Additionally, both sides of the Layla Mattress excel at motion isolation to help you and your partner avoid sleep disturbances.
The Layla Mattress is affordable compared to many competing flippable models. Customers in the contiguous U.S. also receive free ground shipping with their order. The mattress comes with a 120-night sleep trial, and those who keep it are entitled to a lifetime warranty against structural defects.
Amerisleep AS2Best for Back Pain
- Proprietary Bio-Pur memory foam is dense and durable
- Zoned transitional layer provides enhanced support around the midsection
- Great motion isolation and virtually no noise
Amerisleep offers a full line of high-quality memory foam mattresses, each with a distinct feel to accommodate people with different body types, sleep positions, and firmness preferences. The AS2 is one of the brand’s firmer models. A medium firm (6) feel and 12-inch profile provide gentle contouring and sturdy overall support. This all-foam design is especially suitable for people who feel aches and pains in their shoulders, lumbar region, and hips.
The comfort layer is made of Bio-Pur, a proprietary memory foam with a dense composition that helps the material resist deep indentations and impressions. The AS2 also includes a polyfoam transitional layer that is divided into three firmness zones to provide enhanced support around the midsection and a softer, gentler feel elsewhere. High-density foam forms the stabilizing base layer. The AS2’s firmer feel and robust design helps prevent the mattress from sinking along the edges, which is more common in other all-foam models.
Bio-Pur is an open-cell foam engineered to promote airflow and release heat. This material allows users to sleep relatively cool. The cover, made from a stretchy cotton-polyester blend, is also breathable. Like other foam mattresses, the AS2 is effective at isolating motion and reducing transfer across the surface to help couples sleep soundly.
Amerisleep ships the mattress free of charge to customers in the contiguous U.S. Each order comes with a 100-night sleep trial and a 20-year manufacturer’s warranty.
Birch MattressBest Pressure Relief
- Composed of natural, organic, and sustainably sourced materials
- Excellent breathability and temperature control
- Durable design resists wear and tear
The Birch Mattress is a latex hybrid with a medium firm (6) feel. Many sleepers prefer latex for their sleep surface because it contours evenly to the body much like memory foam, but doesn’t hug too closely or retain excessive body heat. A thick Talalay latex comfort layer with gentle cushioning and a robust support core of pocketed coils make the Birch Mattress a great pick for people who weigh at least 130 pounds and feel sharp pressure points in the shoulders, lumbar region, or hips.
The mattress also features two layers of organic wool located directly beneath the surface. This material acts as the fire barrier, and its natural breathability and moisture-wicking properties can help sleepers stay cool and dry on humid nights. The cover is made of organic cotton, which also excels at cooling. Additionally, the cotton is Global Organic Textile Standard Certified.
The natural responsiveness of latex creates a bouncy feel and makes the surface easy to move across. Reinforced perimeter coils also reduce sinkage when you get in and out of bed. Latex is also a highly durable material, giving the Birch Mattress a longer lifespan.
Birch offers free ground delivery to all 50 states. Each mattress purchase includes a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year manufacturer’s warranty.
- Latex and memory foam create a comfortable, balanced feel
- Ample cushioning to support the spine and alleviate pressure
- Latex comfort layer helps prevent heat retention
All-foam mattresses have a reputation for trapping heat and feeling uncomfortably warm. The GhostBed takes a slight edge over its competitors with a top layer composed of latex, which absorbs less heat than foam and sleeps cooler as a result. A secondary layer of memory foam delivers cushioning and even contouring to alleviate pressure, but the latex gives the surface a responsive feel that can make the mattress easier to move across compared to other all-foam beds.
The GhostBed is considered medium firm (6), so the mattress should not hug the body too closely and is suitable for people who weigh up to 230 pounds — especially those who sleep on their backs or stomachs. Although the latex produces a light bounce when you get in and out of bed, the underlying foam layers absorb movement well and excessive motion transfer shouldn’t be an issue for couples.
In addition to the six standard mattress sizes, the GhostBed is available in a split king. This size – which essentially consists of two twin XL mattresses resting side by side – is designed for co-sleepers who share an adjustable bed.
GhostBed offers free ground shipping anywhere in the contiguous U.S. The company’s sleep trial allows you to test out the GhostBed for up to 101 nights, and you receive a lifetime warranty if you decide to keep the mattress.
In-Depth Mattress Guides
Mattress for Specific Needs
Why You Should Trust Us
Each member of the Sleep.org testing team brings years of expertise and experience to our sleep product reviews and recommendations. We personally evaluate each product in our lab and draw feedback from a wide range of ind|as relevant and up-to-date as possible.
What Do I Need To Know About Mattresses To Get a Good Night’s Sleep?
The mattress you use has a major impact on your sleep – for better or worse. We cover everything you need to know about selecting and purchasing a new mattress to help you make an informed shopping decision.
Find the Type of Mattress That Works for You
Choosing a mattress that is suitable for your body type and primary sleep position can alleviate pressure, improve alignment, and help you wake up each morning feeling healthy and well-rested. The wrong mattress can have the opposite effect. Understanding how different mattresses perform in key areas is a good starting point for finding the best model for you.
Pick the Right Mattress Firmness
Firmness is one of the most important considerations when buying a new mattress. Some people prefer a pillow-soft surface, others need a firmer feel with extra reinforcement, and a large number of sleepers want a combination of contouring and support. If you and your partner have different preferences, then a mattress with dual firmness – a different feel on each side – might be the best option.
How to Shop for a New Mattress
In addition to the mattress model you choose, another important element of your shopping experience is deciding whether to make your purchase online or at a brick-and-mortar store. Other considerations include shipping costs, sleep trial length, and warranty coverage.
Every mattress model is unique, but most fall into one of five categories based on their material composition. Each mattress type has its own pros and cons.
A foam mattress is constructed with a comfort layer of memory foam or adaptive polyfoam, as well as support layers made from denser foam. These mattresses often contour closely to the body, which can improve spinal alignment and reduce pressure points in the shoulders, lower back, and hips. Most foam mattresses also excel at motion isolation. People who enjoy slowly sinking into their sleep surface may want to consider a foam mattress.
Hybrid mattresses combine the thick comfort layers of foam and latex mattresses with the coil systems of traditional innersprings. The result is a balance of even contouring and sturdy support. Hybrids tend to alleviate pressure and isolate motion better than innersprings, but consistent air circulation through the coils allows them to sleep cooler than many foam or latex models. The coils also reinforce the edges to prevent deep sinkage.
What About Innerspring Beds?
Traditional innersprings are designed with thin comfort layers and support cores with thick steel coils. They are highly responsive, giving them significant bounce on the surface, and they also sleep quite cool thanks to steady airflow throughout the coil layers. Innersprings are most suitable for people who need extra support and minimal contouring from their mattress.
Latex is a naturally responsive material that conforms to the body without the hugging sensation people associate with memory foam. Sleepers who feel sharp pressure points along the spine but do not enjoy sinking into their mattress are good candidates for an all-latex mattress. Latex also retains less heat than foam and does not deteriorate as quickly. Many of these mattresses use natural or organic latex that contains a low amount of chemicals or synthetic fillers, so they may appeal to eco-conscious individuals as well.
Airbeds – not to be confused with temporary air mattresses often used in guest rooms – are constructed with adjustable air chambers in their support cores. Sleepers can add or release air from these chambers to make their mattress feel softer or firmer. This quality makes airbeds a great choice for anyone whose firmness preferences vary from night to night. Traditional airbeds feature thin comfort layers, but some newer models are designed with thick layers of memory foam or latex for more enhanced comfort.
|Comfort System Size||Significant||Significant||Medium to Significant||None or Minimal||Minimal to Significant|
|Comfort System Material||Memory foam, polyfoam, latex, and/or fabrics||Micro-coils, memory foam, polyfoam, latex, and/or fabrics||Latex||Fabrics or polyfoam||Memory foam, polyfoam, latex, and/or fabrics|
|Support Core||Base Polyfoam||Innerspring Coils||Latex||Innerspring Coils||Air Chambers|
|Typical Longevity||6 to 8 years||6 to 8 years||6 to 10 years||5 years||6 to 8 years|
|General Price Range||$900-1,300||$1,500-2,000||$1,600-2,000||$300-1,100||$2,000-2,400|
|Most Common Strengths||Pressure relief, motion isolation, quiet performance, affordability||Ease of movement, sturdiness, edge support, temperature control||Ease of movement, temperature control, durability||Low price point, ease of movement, temperature control||Adjustable firmness, advanced designs|
|Most Common Weaknesses||Reduced ease of movement, heat retention, off-gassing||Insufficient pressure relief, motion transfer, noise, higher average price||Insufficient pressure relief, motion transfer, heavy/bulky, higher average price||Insufficient pressure relief, motion transfer, reduced durability, noise||High price point, insufficient pressure relief, noise, smaller selection of brands and models|
Scroll L - R for more details
How To Find the Right Mattress Firmness for You
The firmness level or firmness range of a mattress makes it more comfortable for certain sleepers and less so for others. Understanding how body weight and sleep position affect firmness preferences can help guide your decision when choosing a new mattress.
Our Firmness Scale
We evaluate firmness using a 1-to-10 scale, with 1 being the softest and 10 the firmest. Most mattresses made today fall between 3 (soft) and 8 (firm). For most people, the firmness level they prefer depends on how much they weigh and which sleep position they primarily use.
Your Sleeping Position and the Right Firmness for You
Side sleepers tend to feel more pressure along the spine because this position does not promote spinal alignment. As a result, they often need a softer mattress to support their spine and cushion their shoulders and hips. Back sleeping and stomach sleeping do not interfere with alignment as much, but these positions often require extra support to prevent sinkage around the midsection – a common source of aches and pains. As a result, back and stomach sleepers usually prefer medium firm to firm mattresses.
Your Body Weight and the Right Firmness for You
Like sleep positions, your body weight is an important factor when choosing a new mattress. People who weigh less than 130 pounds often prefer softer mattresses because they don’t receive enough cushioning or body contouring from firmer models. Those who weigh 130 to 230 pounds tend to prefer mid-range firmness levels that provide a balance of conforming and support. Sleepers who weigh more than 230 pounds need more support to prevent them from sinking too deeply into their sleep surface, so a firmer feel is usually most suitable.
Putting It All Together
Our general firmness recommendations for different body types and sleep positions are based on our own in-house testing and product research.
|Less Than 130 Pounds||130 to 230 Pounds||More Than 230 Pounds|
|Side Sleepers||Soft (3) to Medium (5)||Medium Soft (4) to Medium Firm (6)||Medium (5) to Firm (7)|
|Back Sleepers||Medium Soft (4) to Medium Firm (6)||Medium (5) to Firm (7)||Medium Firm (6) to Firm (8)|
|Stomach Sleepers||Medium Soft (4) to Medium Firm (6)||Medium Firm (6) to Firm (7)||Medium Firm (6) to Extra Firm (8)|
Scroll L - R for more details
How Can I Figure Out What My Firmness Preferences Are?
One way to figure out your firmness preferences is to evaluate how your current mattress feels. Research the firmness level if you are unsure, then determine if the mattress feels too soft, too firm, or just right. Once you have decided on an ideal firmness level or range, focus on other mattress models with comparable feels. Your preferences may not align with the general consensus in terms of body type and sleep position, so do not feel bound to the recommendations listed above.
What if I’m Still Not Sure What Firmness I Need?
Most online mattress brands offer sleep trials that give you at least 3 months to make a decision, so you can return the mattress for a refund if you are not satisfied with the firmness level. If you are still unsure about which firmness is right for you after testing several mattresses, consider investing in a mattress with more than one firmness level. These options include flippable mattresses with a distinct feel on the top and bottom surfaces, a dual firmness model with a different feel on the left and right sides of the bed, or an airbed with adjustable firmness levels.
How Do I Shop for a New Mattress?
Shopping for a mattress can be challenging and confusing for first-time buyers. To help simplify this process, we’ll walk you through the most important elements and considerations of purchasing a new mattress.
Buying Online vs. In-store
Brick-and-mortar mattress stores give you the opportunity to test out mattresses firsthand and speak with knowledgeable sales staff. However, shoppers are limited to store hours and visiting may require a long drive if you live in a rural area. Additionally, prices tend to be more expensive in stores due to higher overhead costs. Shopping online is easier, more convenient, and typically cheaper by comparison.
Do Your Research and Wait for a Mattress Sale
Knowing the average price-points for different mattress types can help you save money on your purchase. We recommend using the price ranges listed above to help you create a realistic shopping budget. Most online and brick-and-mortar mattress sellers offer substantial sales and discounts throughout the calendar year. Many of these promotions align with federal holidays such as President’s Day, Memorial Day, July Fourth, Labor Day, and Veterans Day, as well as major shopping holidays like Black Friday and Cyber Monday.
Sleep Trials, Warranties, and Free Shipping
Most online mattress brands provide free ground shipping throughout the contiguous U.S., and some extend this offer to Alaska, Hawaii, U.S. territories, and Canada. The mattress is typically compressed, shipped in a box, and delivered to your doorstep. You may also be able to pay extra for White Glove delivery, in which couriers schedule a delivery date and time with you, set up the mattress in a room of your choice, and haul away your old mattress for donation or recycling.
The vast majority of mattresses purchased online include sleep trials that last at least 90 nights, and some allow you to test out the mattress for up to an entire year. We encourage you to take full advantage of these trials. Give yourself as much time as possible to decide whether the mattress is right for you. In most cases, customers receive a full product refund if they return the mattress within the sleep trial period. Many brands also cover the costs for return shipping.
Nearly all mattresses sold today come with a warranty that includes at least 10 years of coverage. Warranties that span 15, 20, and 25 years are also somewhat common, as are lifetime warranties that cover the mattress as long as you own it. Warranties typically cover structural defects such as excessive sinkage, internal components that crack or split, and broken cover zippers. If your mattress has one of these defects, the manufacturer usually pays most or all of the costs to have it repaired or replaced. Other issues such as physical damage or normal wear and tear are not covered under mattress warranties.